This article addresses the issue of ensuring fairness and practical enforceability of court judgments awarding compensation for non-pecuniary damage under Russian law. The author analyzes the criteria for determining the amount of compensation established in law and the practice of higher courts and pays particular attention to whether the financial situation of the harm-doer may be taken into account. The position is substantiated that a defendant’s modest means should not reduce the amount of compensation; rather, this aspect may only be taken into account during the enforcement stage when determining the procedure for recovery. The issue of the impossibility of recovery in cases where the guilty party lacks assets, including in cases of life imprisonment, is examined. It is proposed to establish state designated funds to support victims and to develop methodological guidelines to ensure consistency in judicial practice.