Published Date: 03.10.2024
Феномен «кодифобия» в традиции общего права
Annotation
В литературе распространен не совсем верный стереотип о полном отсутствии кодификации в странах общего права как в их историко-правовом опыте, так и в действующем правовом поле этой семьи. В статье описываются защитная, антикодистическая позиция, которую занимают юристы общего права, их главные контраргументы и попытки обосновать основную угрозу идеи кодификации, представляющей квазиугрозу самому духу общего права. Анализируются причины исторического провала кодификационного проекта в Великобритании и на контрасте вполне успешная теоретическая дискуссия и законодательная кодификация в отдельных британских колониях.
| Type | Article |
| Information | Право между Востоком и Западом № 02/2024 |
Library
1. Morriss A.P. Codification and Right Answers / A.P. Morriss // Chicago-Kent Law Review. 1999. Vol. 74. Р. 355–391.
2. Kötz H. Taking Civil Codes Less Seriously / H. Kötz // Modern Law Review. 1987. Vol. 50. Р. 1–15.
3. Lawson H. A Common Lawyer Looks at Codification // Lawson H. Selected Essays: Many Laws / H. Lawson. North-Holland Publishing Company, 1977. Р. 48–49.
4. Legrand P. Against a European Civil Code / P. Legrand // Modern Law Review. 1997. Vol. 60. Р. 44–59.
5. Legrand P. European Legal Systems are not Converging / P. Legrand // International and Comparative Law Quarterly. 1996. Vol. 45. Р. 52–55.
6. Lieberman D. The Challenge of the Codification in English Legal History / D. Lieberman // The Research Institute of Economy, Trade and Industry (Rieti, July 12, 2009). URL: <a href="https://www.rieti.go.jp/en/events/bbl/09061201.html" target="_blank">https://www.rieti.go.jp/en/events/bbl/09061201.html</a> (дата обращения: 05.04.2024).
7. Masferrer A. The French Codification and ‘Codiphobia’ in Common Law Traditions / A. Masferrer // Tulane European and Civil Law Forum. 2019. Vol. 34. Р. 1–32.
8. Masferrer А. The Passionate Discussion among Common Lawyers about postbellum American Codification: An approach to its Legal Argumentation/ A. Masferrer // Arizona State Law Journal. 2008. Vol. 40. Р. 173–201.
9. Masferrer A. Defense of the Common Law against postbellum American Codification: Reasonable and Fallacious Argumentation / A. Masferrer // American Journal for Legal History. 2008–2009. Vol. 50. Iss. 4. Р. 355–430.
10. McGregor H. Contract Code: Drawn up on behalf of the English Law Commission / H. McGregor. Milano : Giuffre Editore, 1993. 318 p.
11. Hogg M. Codification of Private Law: Scots Law at the Crossroads of Common and Civil Law / M. Hogg // Barker. 2017. № 7. Р. 107–129.
12. Pound R. Codification in Anglo-American Law / R. Pound // The Code Napoleon and the Common Law World / ed. by B. Schwartz. New York : University Press, 1956. Р. 267–268.
13. Shapiro B. Codification of the Laws in Seventeenth-Century England / B. Shapiro // Wisconsin Law Review. 1974. Vol. 2. Р. 428–465.
14. Siems M. Comparative Law / M. Siems. Cambridge University Press, 2022. 530 p.
15. Steiner E. Codification in England: The Need to Move from an Ideological to a Functional Approach ― A Bridge too Far / E. Steiner // Statute Law Review. 2004. Vol. 25. Iss. 3. Р. 209–215.
16. Stoljar S.J. Codification and the Common Law // Stoljar S.J. Problems of Codification / S.J. Stoljar. Canberra : The Australian National University, 1977. Р. 1–15.
17. Tallon D. Codification and Consolidation of the Law at the Present time / D. Tallon // Israel Law Review. 1979. Vol. 14. P. 1–3.
18. The Penal code of the State of New York (State) / ed. by D.D. Field, W.C. Noyes, A.W. Bradford. Albany, Weed, Parsons, 1865. 651 р.
19. Vranken M. Western Legal Traditions: a Comparison of Civil Law & Common Law / M. Vranken. The Federation Press, 2015. 192 p.
20. Farmer L. Reconstructing the English Codification Debate: The Criminal Law Commissioners, 1833–1845 / L. Farmer // Law and History Review. 2000. Vol. 18. Iss. 2. Р. 1–2.
21. Amos A. Ruins of Time, exemplified in Sir Matthew Hale's Pleas of the Crown / A. Amos. London : Stevens and Norton, 1859.
22. Anton A.E. Obstacles to Codification / A.E. Anton // Juridical Review. 1982. Р. 15–30.
23. Barnes W. Contemplating a Civil Law Paradigm for a Future International Commercial Code // Louisiana Law Review. 2005. Vol. 65. Iss. 677. Р. 37–40.
24. Börner Ch. Kodifikation des Common Law: der Civil Code von David Dudley Field / Ch. Börner. Zürich : Schulthess, 2001. 171 p.
25. Caenegem R.C. van. Judges, Legislators and Professors: Chapters in European Legal History / R.C. van Caenegem. Cambridge, 1987. 205 p.
26. Clarke R.F. The Science of Law and Lawmaking / R.F. Clarke. New York, 1898. 473 p.
27. Cook Ch.M. The American Codification Movement, A study of Antebellum legal reform / Ch.M. Cook. Westport : Greenwood Press, 1981. 234 p.
28. Cretney S.M. The Law Commission: True Dawns and False Dawns / S.M. Cretney // The Modern Law Review. 1996. Vol. 59. Iss. 5. P. 631–657.
29. Конвей С. «Бентам проджект» и изучение Бентама // История права: Англия и Россия : сборник статей / под редакций У. Батлера, В. Нерсесянца. Москва : Прогресс, 1990. С. 221–241.
30. Friedman M.L. Codification in the Commonwealth: Earlier Efforts / M.L. Friedman // Criminal Law Forum. 1990. Vol. 2. Р. 144–160.
31. Giliker P. Codification, consolidation, restatement? How best to systemise the modern law of tort / P. Giliker // International & Comparative Law Quarterly. 2021. Vol. 70. Iss. 2. Р. 271–305.
32. Goff R. The Future of the Common Law / R. Goff // International & Comparative Law Quarterly. 1997. Vol. 46. Iss. 4. P. 745–753.
33. Goodrich P. Reading the Law. Critical Introduction to Legal Method and Technique / P. Goodrich. Oxford : Blackwell, 1986. 229 p.
34. Hahlo H.R. Here Lies the Common Law: Rest in Peace / H.R. Hahlo // Modern Law Review. 1967. Vol. 30. Iss. 3. Р. 241–255.
35. Harrington M. The Guide to Government Publications in Australia / M. Harrington. Canberra : Australian Government Publishing Service, 1990. 164 p.
36. Head J. Codes, Cultures, Chaos, and Champions: Common Features of Legal Codification Experiences in China, Europe, and North America / J. Head // Duke Journal of Comparative & International Law. 2003. Vol. 13. Р. 52–88.
37. Hearn W.E. Theory of Legal Rights and Duties: An introduction to Analytical Jurisprudence / W.E. Hearn. Mealburne, 1883. 401 p.
Get access to the article