Judicial Discretion and Law Enforcement Practice in Consumer Protection Disputes within the Tourism Sector
Annotation
he article presents a comprehensive analysis of current judicial practice in resolving consumer disputes within the sphere of domestic and outbound tourism in the Russian Federation. The author consistently examines issues of procedural joinder (involving both tour operators and travel agents), the legal qualification of force majeure circumstances (specifically the pandemic) as grounds for exemption from monetary refunds, as well as the specifics of calculating financial penalties. The paper argues that modern judicial practice has developed stable approaches aimed at protecting the economically weaker party – the tourist; however, the final amount awarded remains subject to active judicial discretion, balancing between the compensatory and preventive functions of civil law. Proposals are formulated for improving legislation with the aim of unifying judicial approaches, limiting the arbitrary actions of professional market participants, and enhancing the enforceability of court decisions.
Keywords
- consumer rights protection
- contract for the sale of a tourist product
- tour operator
- travel agent
- judicial discretion
- reduction of penalty/liquidated damages
- Article 333 of the Civil Code of the RF
- Law on Protection of Consumer Rights
- force majeure
- allocation of liability
- burden of proof
- compensation for moral damage/damages for non-pecuniary harm
- punitive fine
| Type | Article |
| Information | Russian Judge № 12/2026 |
| Pages | 13-17 |
| DOI | 10.18572/1812-3791-2026-12-13-17 |
